500 New & Refreshed Posts, Postings Daily
Over 8,000 Postings & 2,500 Resources
Assisting Buyers & Sellers Over 25 Years!


Should I Buy An Automotive Franchise Or Open My Own Shop? 7 Things To Consider

I was speaking this week with a business buyer looking for an auto service shop in either the San Fernando Valley or Ventura County. He’s a qualified, experienced service manager who’d love to have his own shop and has about $100K cash to invest. He described wanting to build a “substantial” multi-bay operation, not a small one-person shop.

Our discussion led to the subject of franchises and whether the national brand is worth the expense or not. No simple answer. It depends greatly on the financial, emotional and geographic position of the potential franchisee. Many well-funded investors and service technicians have done very well purchasing familiar brand locations like Midas, Jiffy Lube, AAMCO, Meineke, Valvoline and others.


There are many pluses of a franchise over starting an independent shop. You’re buying into a proven concept, which increases your chance of success. The franchise costs are known and identifiable (to you and lenders). You receive valuable initial training and support, along with property management advisory and other soft-cost services that can be very helpful. The long-term risks are eased with a nationally-known brand. Customer loyalty is already established (hopefully). You also have the advantage of an established system of franchisees who’ve gone down this road and can offer assistance. Plus, the franchisor brings buying power and economies of scale to negotiate lower prices for products and services.


But there are numerous downsides needing careful consideration. Starting with capital. Initial startup costs for these shops can go well north of $200K. And that’s not including rent or land purchase costs. You then have ongoing royalty and fees that take substantial bites from your bottom line for years to come. There can be a certain loss of control and independence when adhering to the many requirements of a franchise agreement. Many of the best retail locations have already been taken by well-established franchisees, leaving less-desirable spots as your only options.


1) Big Name Does Not Guarantee Big Bucks - There are many franchise owners who can attest they are not rich, not even close. Quite a few service brand owners are grinding out modest livings. Still, long-term profitability (and survival) is more likely with a franchise.

2) Know Your Market Inside Out - Most technicians and service pros are super-familiar with their local competitors. But often, buying a new shop means going outside the area where you’re most familiar. You’ve gotta be extremely clear where your competition, and your customers, are coming from.

3) Whatever You Think It Will Cost, Add 10% More - Many franchisees I speak with (automotive and elsewhere) say it’s practically inevitable that the process of opening a business will be more expensive and time consuming than you expect.

4) Good Employees are Everything - It’s tough finding young guys who want to work on cars anymore. Just about any owner will tell you, finding first rate technicians and good customer-friendly employees, is everything. Some job-seekers will perceive greater desirability with a national brand. But word-of-mouth is critically important. Workers will follow excellence and opportunity.

5) Thoroughly Investigate Your Franchisor - You should talk to at least three other franchisees before pulling the trigger. They’ve been down the road already. They’ll provide incredible insights whether you might be better off as an independent. Depending on corporate sensitivities and franchise agreements, you may need to use considerable discretion when speaking with the franchisees.

6) Your Personal Skills Are A Huge Factor - Owners who don’t want to get buried in the daily operations are probably better off with a franchise, presuming they can afford it. The same goes for passive investors wanting a GM-run shop. The less shop experience you have, the stronger the argument for buying a franchise.

7) Carefully Consider The Real Risks of Ownership - You may be unhappy where you are and want something new. But as an employee, you can leave. If you buy a business badly - a bad situation, location, business model, franchise fee structure or employee base - you may have a tough time getting your money or sanity back.

Yes, the idea of working for yourself and pocketing profits as an owner sounds good to many. But in the super-competitive, overly-saturated automotive universe, buyers need to carefully consider if the expense and interest in owning a franchise is right for them.

#photo#About The Author: Brian Loring has been a broker since 2005, closing more than $150 Million in business and commercial transactions. He concentrates on serving clients in the San Fernando, Santa Clarita and Antelope Valleys (Los Angeles County). He focuses on the automotive sector, providing unparalleled service to owners and buyers of auto repair, auto body, smog shops, tire, brake and lube shops, and branded and independent gas stations.

Categories: BizBen Blog Contributor, Buying A Business, Franchises For Sale, How To Buy A Business

Place A Posting To Sell Or Buy A Business, Search All Postings

Sell A Business Fast: Place A For Sale Posting Now To Sell A Small Business - 7 Programs To Select From >
Find A Business To Buy Fast: Place A Wanted To Buy Posting Today - Best Way To Find & Buy A Business >
Search Business For Sale & Wanted To Buy Postings On BizBen - 500 New & Refreshed Postings Daily! >

Other Related Blog Posts, Articles, And Discussions You May Be Interested In

Dual Agency Brokers Does Dual Agency Really Work For All? ProIntermediaries Discuss This Topic

Who really represents the buyer? The selling broker or agent through dual agency? Many brokers and agents weigh in on this Discussion on BizBen. Bottomline is all business buyers need to know who really represents them and has their best interest at heart when seeking and negotiating on deals.
Buying A Business Losing Money Should I Buy A Small Business That is Losing Money? Brokers & Agents Discuss

When considering buying a business that is losing money one has to be very careful. There are reasons that the business could be losing money that aren't fatal or extremely difficult to fix and there are other reasons that should send you running in the other direction. ProIntermediaries discuss.
Why Many Deals Fail Why Many Deals Fail: Unrealistic High Asking Prices Are Usually The Culprit

The unfortunate truth is that approximately 50% of all small business sales transactions fall through. While failed transactions can happen for a variety of reasons, Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen Founder & Lead Advisor) discusses the most common reason deals fall through; unrealistic asking prices.
Reason For Not Selling Business What Are Some Possible Reasons My Broker Didn't Sell My Small Business?

What are some reasons a business that was previously on the market with another broker didn't sell? Every broker or agent understands that not every business they list will result in a sale. There can be many reasons small businesses don't sell and many are discussed on this BizBen Discussion post.
Buying A Janitorial Service Janitorial Cleaning Services: 6 Considerations When Buying A Janitorial Firm

Buyers interested in buying a janitorial cleaning business will find companies in this industry for sale that are quite profitable. Careful due diligence, including the six factors covered in this blog post, is advised before completing a deal. Peter Siegel, MBA with BizBen explores this industry.
Questions When Buying A Liquor Store Buying A Liquor Store: 3 Questions To Consider And Ask Before You Purchase

Buying a liquor store? First, ask yourself these three critical questions to find out if owning a liquor store is right for you. Questions like hands on vs absentee ownership, inventory turnover, licensing issues. Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen ProBuy & ProSell Program Lead Advisor) explores this topic.
Key Factors Play A Role When Selling When To Sell Your Small Business - Many Key Important Factors Play A Part

Determining the right time to sell a private business is as much an art as a science, because there are so many factors at play and each business is unique. The timing of a business sale is critical. Christina Lazuric, CBI, Orange County Business Broker discusses this topic on this BizBen Blog post.
Appealing To Restaurant Buyers During COVID Tips On Selling A Restaurant: Appealing To Restaurant Buyers During COVID-19

ProIntermediary, Joe Ranieri (Business Broker) shares what buyers are looking for in this unprecedented market. COVID-19 has made curb appeal more important than ever when selling a restaurant. Sellers still have the power to attract buyers in this market with focus of a few key requirements.
Pocket Listings Pocket Listings: Vast Hidden Market Or Myth With Business Buyers & Sellers?

What percentage of businesses for sale that are advertised and/or sold are pocket listings? What is the best way to find out about pocket listings? Are they advertised? Are they a big part of the businesses sold marketplace? In this Discussion ProIntermediaries and ProAdvisors discuss this topic.
How To Buy A Dry Cleaners Finding A Dry Cleaner Small Business For Sale That Will Be A High Performer

Before you buy a dry cleaners small business, read these critical tips about this industry. Discover why a dry cleaner needs to be "green" to be profitable. Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen ProBuy, ProSell Program Advisor) explores this topic and other helpful strategies on buying a dry cleaning store.