Share This Info:  

Cash Based Businesses: How Do I Confirm Cash Being Represented?

See All Discussions   •   See All Contributors   •   All New Discussions & Comments

Comments & Replies: 6     Views: 5722     Posted By: Peter Siegel MBA  Peter Siegel MBA: BizBen Founder, ProBuy/ProSell Program Director

A buyer who I have been consulting with on the BizBen ProBuy Program is looking to buy a liquor store (and possible other "cash" oriented businesses). They asked me how they should verify cash being generated by the business and how to go about conducting due diligence etc.

Topics: Buying A Business, Due Diligence     Tags: buying a business, deal structures, due diligence



A buyer who I have been consulting with on the BizBen ProBuy Program is looking to buy a liquor store (and possible other "cash" oriented businesses). They asked me how they should verify cash being generated by the business and how to go about conducting due diligence, considering that these are mostly all-cash businesses. This buyer also wanted to know if the seller's suggestion about having an observation last one week, is a long enough period of time to verify income.

My answer to this potential business buyer was basically this (but I know there are probably many other solutions to this situation that I am not aware of):

This question comes up frequently from buyers of mostly cash based businesses. They don't have the benefit of a "money trail" to examine, as do buyers who conduct due diligence on a company that sends invoices to its customers and posts all transactions in some kind of record that can then be verified with bank statements.

There is no fool-proof way to verify sales of an all-cash business unless the buyer is "stationed" on premises for several days during the time the business is open, to make note of every transaction. And even that's not a perfect method. Sellers have been known to ask friends and relatives to come to the business, pretend to be strangers, and make a purchase during the due diligence period. That tactic could give the buyer the impression the business conducts more sales and collects more money than is normally the case. And I know of a situation in which a buyer "observed" a gift shop during an unusually slow period. She didn't believe the seller's explanation that there's usually more business than occurred during the due diligence week. Another buyer with a back-up offer was able to close a deal on the business. The first buyer later learned that sales had, in fact, been slower than usual during her due diligence observation, and was sorry she didn't believe the seller's explanation.

Sellers aren't always agreeable to the idea of someone "lurking" around their place of business for a week or longer, because it can disturb customers and employees. And it might be obvious that the business is for sale if people conclude that the person is checking out the amount of sales conducted. A typical seller solution is that he or she will save each day's cash register tape, if the business has that capability, for examination by the buyer after the business closes. That's only an effective way to conduct due diligence if the seller is careful to ring up the exact amount of each transaction, and not post exaggerated amounts or ring-up "make believe" sales.

One solution a buyer proposed was that different members of his family would come to observe at different times, acting like customers. Another suggestion was that the buyer be permitted to operate the cash register, under the pretense that he was a new employee being trained, during what actually was the due diligence period. That worked well in connection with a deal for a dry cleaning plant. Due diligence began the day after the agreement was signed so the money collected, at least during the first few days, would represent work on garments and linen that had been brought in before the sales agreement. There was no chance the business had been "staged" with customers.

The seller who brags that there is more income than is shown on the books - that some of the cash goes directly into his pocket, is likely to be just as dishonest with a buyer as with the taxing authorities.

There is no established period of time over which due diligence should be conducted. The custom is a ten day or two-week period during which the buyer looks into the business more thoroughly than when he was viewing it before and during negotiations. Many, if not most deals call for a two-week due-diligence period. Sellers reluctant to let the buyer have that much time might have something to hide, but more likely just doesn't want the due diligence process to disrupt the business and "frighten" employees, customers, and vendors.

Rather than insisting on a very short due diligence period, the seller might look at that investment of time as legal insurance, reducing the likelihood of the buyer claiming there was not enough time to really analyze the business and then suing the seller for misrepresenting critical facts about the business offering.

----------------------

So fellow BizBen Users - what words of wisdom, tips would you have for buyers who are looking to buy cash based businesses - how do you deal with these types of businesses and verify their claims of income, etc? What strategies would you suggest buyers implement to verify income and feel comfortable with this type of business purchase - both in the pre-sale and due diligence stages of a possible business purchase? Please give your thoughts, examples of past deals, and ideas via the Comments section below.


This is a tough situation and all of Peter's suggestions are beneficial, depending on the situation. No one method works for all transactions and I would counsel a buyer to use a few redundant methods to be truly confident in their conclusions about the "off-books" cash.

One very important caveat is Peter's statement: "The seller who brags that there is more income than is shown on the books - that some of the cash goes directly into his pocket, is likely to be just as dishonest with a buyer as with the taxing authorities."

I have encountered additional methods that a buyer might consider if the resources exist.

Sometimes the owner won't report the income but will regularly deposit the cash in their own or a relative's personal bank account. The buyer can be shown these accounts.

One seller allegedly had several years worth of cash stashed in safe deposit boxes and offered to show any serious buyer their stacks of U.S. currency.

Some buyers will have notebooks of some kind. Frankly, the messier the better.

In other words, be very sure that these notes were actually produced contemporaneously over the years and not concocted just when a sale of the business was pending.

Final caveat: the new buyer hopefully is going to be more honest than the seller; therefore, the taxes that will be paid on this cash income will diminish the amount inuring to the benefit of the buyer. In other words, any buyer should consider the after-tax value of any heretofore unreported cash when determining the real cash flow (or SDE) and the value of the business to the new owner.


I try not to judge people, since most people who judge haven't been backed into a corner before. I'm not saying that people should do the wrong thing, but after studying the books and records of hundreds of businesses in Orange County, I can honestly say that its a tough place to make a buck. Entrepreneurs are typically survivors by nature and they will find a way because they have to.

In my experience, the larger the business the less shenanigans with the books. There are several ways to find out what's really going on in a business but you should be buying the business for what YOU can do in it because there are really no guarantees when you own your own business. One of The best ways to know what the real gross is to just focus on the receipts for the COG (cost of goods). If you can accurately be sure the COG is right, then calculate what the margin should be (because it should be too high on the P&L) then you'll know what the real income was. Just make sure you've accounted for a variation in inventory year to year.

There's huge element of chance when buying any business. Buyers who are realistic about their expectations end up being successful. A cynical buyer once gave me a good laugh when he said, "I don't think he (the seller) is lying by more then 10%, let's make an offer". If buyers look at he worst case scenario and its still acceptable, then they are going in with eyes open and they will probably land on their feet.

Contributor: Business Broker, Northern California

There is an expression in business brokerage that says that if a seller receives cash and doesn't show it on their business tax returns, then they can't expect it to be included as part of the sale of their business and therefore be paid twice.

Additionally, a bank will not lend to the buyer of a business any data that doesn't show on a tax return as they know that if the seller of the business is audited by the IRS and found to have not declared any income the business can be shut down.

A new concern for business sellers that do not report all their income but want a buyer to recognize it when selling their business is that the IRS and now the State of CA have whistle blower programs.

Replies To This Comment
 
Any prudent buyer will also look at the after-tax value of any unreported cash income claimed by the seller, if the buyer will consider it at all. By counting the cash income at its pre-tax value, sellers can have unrealistic expectations about the true value of their business.


Contributor: Business Appraisals, Valuations Advisor

When I do an appraisal on a business that may have cash income that is not on the books, I inform the client that the appraisal would be based only on the financial statements and tax returns. If there is any cash not reported it is up to the client to decide if he wants to believe it or not, but I will not include it in the appraisal. There are certain types of businesses that I avoid doing appraisals on because I don't believe I could provide an accurate appraisal.

Replies To This Comment
 
Appraisals or market evaluations of a business can only be based on verifiable facts. Bob is absolutely right--unreported cash is unverifiable and has no place in determining market value.

As a business broker, I am asked to establish a reasonable market value for the businesses I represent. I'm brutally frank with sellers claiming unreported cash income: they have already gotten their return on that money--illegal as it may be, and they will not get it a second time from a any sensible buyer. In fact, they may get even less because the buyer doesn't know how trustworthy the seller is about other matters.

My advice to business owners who have been hiding income and who now want to sell their business for top value: start reporting the income, show a dramatic increase in revenue, and sell the business a year from now.



It's very easy for a Seller to say they take an additional $10K in cash per month out of the business. It's much harder to prove it - if they even want to go down that path. And given the number of credit card/debit card transactions these days, I think the days of 50% of your sales as unreported cash are gone.

That said, I think it boils down to a couple of things:

1. Does the unreported cash makes sense given the type of business and industry norms? For example, if a small pizza shop is doing $300K per year in revenues, showing 25% food cost ($60K), and shows a book profit of $60K per year, that makes sense. But if the seller says he is taking another $100K out per year in cash, look at what those unreported revenue does to the food cost. Basically the seller is saying revenues are really $400K, but since his actual food costs dollars spent didn't increase, how that $60K in food costs represents 15% of revenue. Pizza food costs are low, but you have to ask yourself is that even possible? I think each case of unreported cash needs to pass the "sniff test."

2. As a broker, I have three rules regarding unreported cash. First, the Seller must sign off on the advertised net which would include the cash. I am not going to represent any number that the seller will not sign off on themselves. Second, I don't want to be involved with the due diligence on unreported cash. The buyer and seller can meet and discuss anything they like, but I don't want to be a part of it. And Third, if there is an outside lender involved, I will NOT be part of it. It's one thing for a buyer who is paying cash, or doing a deal with seller financing, to make a decision about the viability of a business that has unreported cash. But quite another to be involved with a transaction where the lender is a third party and likely using the SBA guaranteed loan program. Its just not worth it!




  Helpful Resources To Assist In Selling And Buying California Businesses
Hasan Abdullah, Esq. E-2, Immigration Legal Assistance

I have over 10 years experience with E-2's and immigration issues. E-2's approved for as little as $10,000. Let me assist you with E-2 visa strategies when buying and selling a small to mid-sized California business. Mention BizBen.com for a FREE consultation when phoning me direct at 510-500-1155.

Diane Boudreau-Tschetter: Escrow And Bulk Sale Services

California Business Escrow, Inc. is a full service independent escrow company serving all of California and has expertise in a wide range of escrows. Our team prides itself on providing an exceptional escrow experience. For more info phone Diane Boudreau-Tschetter at 888-383-3331 or 209-838-1100.

Elizabeth McGovern: Escrow Services - SF Bay Area

McGovern Escrow Services, Inc., is a leading independent escrow company. We are a trusted partner with our clients, assisting them through the tangled bulk sale & liquor license transfer process. We provide attentive, quality & innovative customer service. Phone Elizabeth McGovern at 415-735-3645.

Willard Michlin, CPA, Certified Fraud Examiner, Due Diligence Services

Willard Michlin, CPA #106752, offers buyers step by step training & assistance in doing Due Diligence Services when they are thinking of making an offer, or are in process of investigating a business purchase. He helps to determine the actual net profit even when there is cash. Call 805-428-2063.

Brad Steinberg, Broker - Laundromat Specialists

PWS is the leading laundromat broker in California. Since 1968 PWS has brokered over 2,500 laundromat sales. With over 90 employees dedicated to the coin laundry industry, PWS has 18 licensed agents, a 3 person in-house finance department, 10 service technicians and a 20 person parts department.

Mark Chatow, Esq.: Legal Services For Buying, Selling Businesses

Mark has a broad range of small business purchase & sale experience from analyzing potential acquisition targets to successfully guiding buyers and sellers through the purchase & sale of small businesses. Mark can assist with contracts, negotiations, legal matters, etc. Reach Mark at 949-478-8393.

Janet Carrera - Escrow & Bulk Sale Services - SF Bay Area

Redwood Escrow Services, Inc. is a full service, licensed independent escrow company. We are EAFC Fidelity bonded, fully insured & licensed with the Department of Corporations. Committed to offering our clients the most comprehensive variety of escrow services available. Phone Janet at 510-247-0741.

Helen Yoo: Escrow & Bulk Sale Services - Southern California

New Century Escrow, Inc. is a fully licensed & bonded independent escrow company. Over 20 years combined experience in handling bulk escrow transactions. Multi-lingual staff that speaks your language, including Korean, Chinese, Vietnamese. Call Helen Yoo direct at 626-890-1151.


  Related Articles, Events, Blog Posts, Discussions, Videos, Interviews
5 Myths About Selling A California Business: Best Tips For Sellers & Brokers

Peter Siegel, MBA (at 866-270-6278) - BizBen Director discusses myths associated with the process of selling a business and some of them can actually cause deals to fall through. Don't let your sale be comprised, be aware of these common misconceptions related to the process of selling a business.

Financing A Business Purchase With Limited Or No Real Estate Collateral

In my experience working with the "right banks and financial institutions" repayment ability sometimes overrules collateral pledged by someone needing financing for a business purchase or a down payment. Peter Siegel, MBA (Business Purchase Financing Expert) at 866-270-6278 shares his experience.

Live Podcast: A Buyers Perspective- My Experiences & Buyer Tips - 11/14

Mike is a seasoned Business Buyer and a member of the BizBen ProBuyProgram. On this Podcast he will discuss his past experiences dealing with brokers and business sellers and relay helpful advice to new buyers who may be starting the experience of seeking to buy a small or mid-sized business in CA.

Why Deals Fall Out: Unrealistic High Asking Prices Are Usually The Reason

The unfortunate truth is that approximately 50% of all small business sales transactions fall out. While failed transactions can happen for a many reasons, Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen Director & Business Purchase Financing Expert) discusses the main reason deals fall through; steep asking prices.

If You Plan To Offer Seller Financing: 3 Things Owner Sellers Need to Know

When selling your business, offering seller financing is a great way to help your business standout from others on the market and it is also a good strategy to consider that can help you close a sale. Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen ProSel Program & Financing Expert) explains. Reach him at 866-270-6278.

Should I Buy A Business That is Losing Money? Feedback From Top Advisors

Are businesses worth taking a look at when they are losing money? Multiple Advisors & Business Brokers weigh in on this topic and say yes! (but be careful) on a BizBen Discussion. Some great feedback on this topic will make potential business buyers (and money losing sellers) want to read this info!

Uncover Hidden Problems In Due Diligence When You Buy A Small Business

Most everyone who's decided to buy a small business in California knows the importance of due diligence. That involves close examination of a business prior to removing contingencies. But not everyone knows how to uncover problems that are not obvious. Here are five of the most common hidden issues.

Before Buying A California Business, 10 Questions You Should Ask Yourself

Before buying a business, all serious business buyers should ask themselves some key questions about possible buying a small California business, franchise, or opportunity - from Peter Siegel, MBA (Business Purchase Financing Expert, ProBuy & ProSell Program Advisor with BizBen) at 866-270-6278.

See All News, Tips And Events

Chris Lazurik Business Broker
Tim Cunha Business Brokerage
Ken Oppeltz, Business Broker
Business Purchase Financing SBA Loans
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Google Plus You Tube
Vlogs and Podcasts


Auto Related
Business Services
Children Related
Communication Related
Computer, Internet Related
Construction Related
Entertainment Related
Financial Services
Health, Beauty Related
Home Improvement Related
Maintenance Related
Manufacturing Related
Media, Publishing Related
Pet Related
Photography/Video Related
Real Estate Services
Restaurant, Food Related
Retail Related
Service Related
Sports Related
Transportation Related
Travel Related
Wholesale Related

Auto Body Shops
Auto Repair Shops
Bakeries
Bars, Sports Bars
Cafe Restaurants
Car Washes
Cleaning Services
Clothing, Apparel Stores
Coffee Shops
Convenience Stores
Deli Restaurants
Discount, Dollar Stores
Dry Cleaners
eCommerce Websites
Fast Food Restaurants
Florists, Flower Shops
Full Service Restaurants
Gas Stations
Gift Shops
Gyms, Fitness Facilities
Home Health Agencies
Hotels/Motels
Ice Cream Shops
Juice, Smoothie Shops
Laundromats
Liquor Stores
Markets, Marts
Nightclubs
Pizza Restaurants
Postal, Shipping Stores
Preschools, Day Care
Print Shops
Salons, Beauty Shops
Sandwich Shops
Smog Test Only Shops
Smoke Shops
Spas, Med Spas
Sushi Restaurants
Tire Shops
Towing Services
Vending Routes
Wireless, Cellular Shops
Yogurt Shops

Alameda
Alpine
Amador
Butte
Calaveras
Colusa
Contra Costa
Del Norte
El Dorado
Fresno
Glenn
Humboldt
Imperial
Inyo
Kern
Kings
Lake
Lassen
Los Angeles
Madera
Marin
Mariposa
Mendocino
Merced
Modoc
Mono
Monterey
Napa
Nevada
Orange
Placer
Plumas
Riverside
Sacramento
San Benito
San Bernardino
San Diego
San Francisco
San Joaquin
San Luis Obis
San Mateo
Santa Barbara
Santa Clara
Santa Cruz
Shasta
Sierra
Siskiyou
Solano
Sonoma
Stanislaus
Sutter
Tehama
Trinity
Tulare
Tuolumne
Ventura
Yolo
Yuba

0 to $99,999
$100,000 to $249,999
$250,000 to $499,999
$500,000 to $999,999
$1 million to $2 million
over $2 million




BizBen - Where California Deals Get Done! 888-212-4747
7172 Regional Street #364 · Dublin, CA. 94568
BizBen · Copyright © 1994 - 2018, All Rights Reserved

               Vlogs and Podcasts  
Join Us On Social Media - Content Updated Daily
Sign Up Today - For Our FREE BizBen Weekly Email Newsletter
Includes The Best Info On Buying, Selling, Valuing, Financing California Businesses:
Articles, Blog Posts, Podcasts, Videos/Vlogs, Discussions, Q&A, Workshops, Webinars,
Resources. Watch For An Email Confirmation After Signing Up Above. Thank you.
Clost Login


Please confirm your registration by clicking the link we've sent to .

If you can't see it, please check your junk mail folder.

If you have any problems registering, or need assistance with your new BizBen User Account please phone BizBen Customer Support at 888-212-4747.



First Name:*
Last Name:*
Email Address:*
Confirm Email:*
Create Password:*
Confirm Password:*
Phone:
(   
 


You Are A:
Individual
 
Intermediary
 

Email Address:
Password:
 
Search BizBen.com

500 New & Refreshed Detailed Postings Daily
Over 2500 Resources Available On BizBen
Since 1994. Where California Deals Get Done!
Live Podcast: A Buyers Perspective- My Experiences & Buyer Tips - 11/14
Read More News
4 Reasons Why Business Brokers Do Not Cooperate With Other Brokers & Age...
Read More News