Who Really Represents The Business Buyer? Does Dual Agency Work?

Comments & Replies: 11     Views: 20190     Posted By: Peter Siegel MBA  Peter Siegel MBA: BizBen Founder, Lead Advisor

Who really represents the buyer? The selling broker or agent through dual agency? Many brokers and agents weigh in on this Discussion on BizBen. Bottomline is all business buyers need to know who really represents them and has their best interest at heart when seeking and negotiating on deals.

Topics: Business Brokerage, Buying A Business, Selling A Business     Tags: business brokers, buyer representation, buying a business, legal issues



Technically and legally, it is the seller of a business whom the business sales intermediary represents in a sale. The contract forming the relationship is typically a listing agreement. The broker with that agreement and any other broker who procures the buyer, are bound by that contract, and so they are contractually representing the seller.

While there are many instances that might be referred to as "dual agency," by which the broker who represents the seller also brings the buyer, the legal basis of these relationships is the broker's responsibility to the seller. The broker does, however, have a legal responsibility of "fair dealing" with the buyer, consistent with the use of ethical practices in working with all parties.

Yes, what is referred to as "dual agency" can work in a business sales transaction if the broker discloses the nature of his or her relationships to all parties in a transaction and is careful not to share with one party any confidential information regarding the other party.

In other words, the sales intermediary should not reveal to the seller or to the buyer the negotiating limits, in price and terms (for example, the highest price to which the buyer will agree or the lowest price the seller will accept), that the other party has revealed in confidence to that intermediary.

Contributor: Business Appraisals, Valuations Advisor

The seller's broker has a fiduciary responsibility to the seller but he also has a responsibility to treat the buyer with the same level of honesty and cooperation. I sold businesses for 23 years with duel agency. Cooperating with other brokers made everything more complicated. Instead of having three people involved in the transaction now you have four. The buyer's broker would have to go through me to ask a question of the seller. I would have to ask the seller the question with no other details and then tell the buyer s broker the answer and never know how the answer went over with the buyer or if he was ever told the correct answer. I think the length of the last few sentences tells it all. With a Buyer broker I totally missed out at getting to know the buyer, understanding his needs and helping him build a good relationship with the seller. If you feel you need a broker on your side you have the right to do so.

Contributor: Transactional Attorney

While dual agency works reasonably well for the sale of homes, there are a lot of problems with it in the more complex world of business transactions.

To give a specific example, I represented the buyer recently in a transaction where the broker had provided a P&L that was about one quarter behind and a pro forma income statement showing projections through year end.

When I took a quick look at the numbers it was very clear that things were not adding up. Even accounting for seasonality the actuals could not have supported the projections. When I talked with the broker about it he admitted that he wasn't sure how the numbers added up either but that he was, "just passing on what the seller had provided".

That is the key problem with dual agency. If a broker is going to just "pass along" what the seller provides then they are not taking an active role in representing the interests of the buyer. At the same time, if they alert the buyer to problems proactively are they fulfilling their duty to the seller?

I agree with Bob that having someone represent the buyer can slow down a transaction and may not allow the one-on-one connection you have in dual agency. But I believe the risks far outweigh the relatively minor benefits of dual agency.

If the buyer is represented by a competent broker or attorney who is incentivized to watch out for the buyer's best interests and--not just to close a deal--it can be beneficial to all parties.

The buyer has someone in their corner whose only job is to make sure they are protected, and the Seller can be assured that the buyer goes into the transaction with full knowledge and can possibly avoid legal issues down the line.


With my academic and professional background as a lawyer, "dual agency" has never made any sense to me. The agent's primary fiduciary obligation is to the principal, "the master." "No man can serve two masters ... (Matt. 6:24)" is as true for business transactions as it is for theology. While, as a licensed broker I have a fiduciary obligation of integrity and fair dealing to all parties, my obligation to my principal should not be compromised by confusion concerning who it is I represent.

When I have listed a business for sale, I am representing the seller. My contract makes it abundantly clear that I am the agent of the seller, NOT the buyer. In most cases, buyers inquire about a business for sale directly and I deal with them directly; but, I advise them that they should not enter into an offer or a contract without seeking professional advice, preferably from an attorney. In fact, once the buyer has contacted us about a business and has received disclosure of the seller's information, a "buyer's broker" serves little if any purpose. At that point, the buyer should be consulting with an attorney and a CPA, especially during due diligence. Unfortunately, tall too often, the buyer will not make the relatively minor investment of retaining an attorney to review documents and a CPA to review financials; it's foolish--"an ounce of prevention IS worth a ton of cure."

Very important: The buyer should retain only an attorney and a CPA experienced in business law and business ownership transfer transactions. This is a specialized area, and too many professionals think they know everything about everything. Having a business law specialist, like Mark Chatow, Esq. in Southern California (Newport Beach) at the buyer's side will be worth far more than the nominal cost.

Replies To This Comment
 
Contributor: Transactional Attorney  Post ID: 783
Thanks Tim, I appreciate the mention and I second the recommendation to bring in a qualified CPA as well.



I'm sorry but I have to disagree with both of you. Dual agency can be a slippery slope, I agree on that! If the broker isn't totally ethical then there can be a problem, but in that case you'll surely have some other problem at some point. After literately hundreds of deals and 99% of them duel agency, I can honestly say that the purchase price is really the only awkward issue.

I have a way of handling it and I disclose it to ALL my clients. I tell them to do whatever they feel is fair & right. Unless I have been given specific instructions by the seller to not even present something below a certain number, I tell the buyer that the seller can counter of he doesn't like it. On deals when I had to work with another broker, I found could be more difficult for me because its another personality thrown in the mix. Not every broker is as fast at responding, thorough, or can translate information so that its not inflammatory.

The bottom line is that EVERYTHING has to be disclosed, regardless of whom it benefits and whom it detriments. My job is to navigate two parties that mutually want to close a deal but given that small businesses are run by regular individuals not large corporations, emotionally charge clients are part of the territory. My role becomes mediator and I have found that it is not a gift everyone possesses. Perhaps dual agency isn't for everyone but it can be done with integrity, when handled correctly.

Replies To This Comment
 
Every licensed professional is certainly free to conduct their business as they see fit, within the law. My choice, and in my humble opinion, the prudent choice is to serve one principal, not two. And, I don't agree that "EVERYTHING has to be disclosed." If, for example, I knew that my seller had a child with a critical medical condition that would make the seller more susceptible to a "low-ball" offer, it would be derelict of me to "disclose" that to the buyer; but, if I were the buyer's agent as well, I might very well have an obligation to do so. My sellers are very well served knowing that I represent them and their best interests alone, without the specter of potential divided loyalties haunting the transaction.


Contributor: Business Broker, Northern California

This is an interesting topic and so I'll add my perspective. I agree with Christina and think Dual Agency is very much a positive for both buyer and seller and this is supported by the comments below.

For example, Mark suggests Dual Agency doesn't work as the sale of a business is more complex than selling a home. This is the reason Dual Agency does work because Mark is correct, the sale of a business is much more complicated. Without fail, the only reason a business or most transactions get done is due to good communication. If the communication is poor then the result will be poor. When communication takes place with many parties it tends to break down. Email is probably one of the poorest forms of communication.

The benefit of Dual Agency is that one broker is the pivot between all the communication between the buyer, seller, landlord, lender, attorney's, CPA's and more. If there is a misunderstanding and the broker knows what they are doing, this will be caught and resolved.

Probably the greatest benefit of Dual Agency is that the broker is the party representing the business. That is, the business can't speak for itself as no one is supposed to know the business is for sale except the seller and the buyer and disinterested third parties. The broker wants to get a deal done as quickly as possible if the buyer and seller want to do a deal as they know that the business is vulnerable while their are negotiations and its therefore in limbo.

As a Certified Business Broker I really don't care on how much the buyer pays or the seller accepts - that's their decision and responsibility. My responsibility is to disclose EVERYTHING so that a motivated buyer and a motivated seller knowing the full facts of a deal can decide if they wish to do a transaction.

To Timothy's point, I am not serving two masters. I am serving two customers. There is only one Master which is the business and I see my role as protecting it and making sure if no deals get done, the business is in the same condition as when I was hired to try and sell it.

I also agree with other comments that a bad broker is a problem. This is the reason to look for a Certified Business Broker as they have training and certification to support their skills.

Replies To This Comment
 
I think Andrew has nailed it: The business owner needs to decide if he wants his broker representing him, his interests, his profit, his future, or representing the interests, profits, and future of the business he's selling. Once the business owner determines where his best interests lie -- in his own reward from the business or the prospects for the business in the future -- then he can make an informed decision as to whether to retain a "seller's agent" or a "dual agent."


Contributor: Business Appraisals, Valuations Advisor

I have to agree with Christina. If you have integrity, are honest and open with both the buyer and seller, dual agency works. I actually wanted the buyer to understand the short comings of the business and the seller to feel comfortable trusting in the buyer. Many times I told a seller I wasn t happy with a buyer we were working with, and with his agreement I looked for a new buyer. My goal was not just to sell the business but to sell it to the right person. I never pushed a seller into a sale. I gave him my advice but I made sure it was his decision. I didn t follow through with some buyers because they didn t fit the type of person needed to run the business. I knew I was only looking for one buyer and my experience told me that he would show up. I always did my best to help a buyer get all the information he needed, answer all his questions and help him work his way through the purchase process. Most buyers had never purchased a business before and it was my responsibility to help them through the entire process.


In any transaction where I represent the seller, I always tell the buyer that while I am the agent of the seller, I have a legal, ethical, and moral obligation to deal fairly and honestly with all parties and reveal all relevant material facts that are known to me. Once a buyer has found a business on their own without the assistance of a broker, once they have assessed the value of the business they are buying, and certainly once they have submitted an offer, they no longer need a "buyer's broker" to enter into the transaction. What they need at that point is a good CPA ad a good business transaction lawyer. Whether the buyer does or does not have a broker, I always strongly recommend that they retain competent professional accounting and legal advisors.


We primarily represent Buyers in a specific industry (Vended Laundries) that we are experts in. So in these cases it actually makes for a smoother and more transparent transaction.

I would not recommend any broker taking on a listing of a highly specialized business, without outside resources who do specialize. In a recent litigation that I was designated as an Expert Witness, the Broker had no knowledge of the industry and used that lack of knowledge as his defense when everything was finally discovered,; after the transaction. Sorry! You might get away with that but you better be sure to put the Buyer in touch with experts and make sure that all is transparent in the transaction and that good diligence is performed.

While no broker can be knowledgeable about every business, he does have the role of presenting the facts. So, unless the Buyer is well familiar with the business model it is advisable to seek knowledgeable people.

Contributor: Broker/Consultant: Elderly Care Services

Dual Agency is a topic that I think will never be resolved. This is a topic that will never go away and most likely for good reason.

All too often Business Brokers forget what their true job is; and that is simply to bring Buyers and Sellers together.

Sure there are a ton of other activities a Business Broker will be involved in such as writing offers, negotiating on behalf of all Clients, assisting in due diligence, hand holding, encouragement and such.

But at the end of the day the successful Business Broker who operates his/her business with integrity and honesty will always encourage their Buyers and Sellers to seek a licensed professional such as an Attorney or CPA to review all documents and due diligence items.


  Helpful Resources To Assist In Selling And Buying California Businesses
Elizabeth McGovern: Escrow Services - San Francisco Bay Area

McGovern Escrow Services, Inc., is a leading independent escrow company. We are a trusted partner with our clients, assisting them through the tangled bulk sale & liquor license transfer process. We provide attentive, quality & innovative customer service. Phone Elizabeth McGovern at 415-735-3645.

Brad Steinberg, Business Broker: Laundromat Specialist

PWS is the leading laundromat broker in California. Since 1968 PWS has brokered over 2,500 laundromat sales. With over 90 employees dedicated to the coin laundry industry, PWS has 18 licensed agents, a 3 person in-house finance department, 10 service technicians and a 20 person parts department.

Helen Yoo, New Century Escrow - Escrow Services In Southern California

New Century Escrow, Inc. is a fully licensed & bonded independent escrow company. Over 20 years combined experience in handling bulk escrow transactions. Multi-lingual staff that speaks your language, including Korean, Chinese, Vietnamese. Call Helen Yoo direct at 626-890-1151.

Diane Boudreau-Tschetter: Escrow & Bulk Sale Services - CA

California Business Escrow, Inc. is a full service independent escrow company serving all of California and has expertise in a wide range of escrows. Our team prides itself on providing an exceptional escrow experience. For more info phone Diane Boudreau-Tschetter at 888-383-3331 or 209-838-1100.

Janet Carrera: Escrow & Bulk Sale Service - SF Bay Area

Redwood Escrow Services, Inc. is a full service, licensed independent escrow company. We are EAFC Fidelity bonded, fully insured & licensed with the Department of Corporations. Committed to offering our clients the most comprehensive variety of escrow services available. Phone Janet at 510-247-0741.

Shalonda Chappel: Escrow & Bulk Sale Services - Southern California

Escrow services to brokers/agents, sellers, & buyers. Established 43 years. Extraordinary service. Experienced with handling difficult transactions. One stop for all your escrow needs: Bulk sales, lien searches, UCC searches, liquor license transfers, publishing & recording services. 951-808-3972.

William F. Ziprick, Attorney: Legal Services For Buyers And Sellers

Through creative problem solving, attention to detail, accessibility, & understanding that unnecessary delay is often a deal killer, I work closely with my clients and other professionals to consistently achieve a high rate of closings. Office: 909-255-8353, Cell: 509-951-7230.


  Related Articles, Events, Blog Posts, Discussions, Videos, Interviews
Unreported Income Cash Claims By The Seller-What Should A Business Buyer Do?

One of the most difficult challenges when purchasing a California small business is expressed by a prospective buyer of a liquor store who is told by the owner/seller that there is more money being made than shows up on the books. Should this buyer accept that statement and go ahead with the deal?

Financing A Business Purchase With Limited Or No Real Estate Collateral

In my experience working with the "right banks and financial institutions" repayment ability sometimes overrules collateral pledged by someone needing financing for a business purchase or a down payment. Peter Siegel, MBA (Business Purchase Financing Expert) at 925-785-3118 shares his experience.

Back-Up Offers: Crucial When Buying Or Selling A California Small Business

An often overlooked aspect of selling (or buying) a small business is taking back-up offers during the entire process of selling (or buying) a business. Most sellers (or buyers) don't realize that over fifty percent of all deals/contracts fall out escrow or contract for one reason or another.

Thinking Of Selling My Business: What Factors Create Value And Drive Price?

There are a lot of misconceptions about what enhances the value of a business. The following factors in this Discussion Post on BizBen are aspects of a business that really drives its value and pricing. Business owners thinking of selling should check these out these factors before selling.

Top 100 List: This Week's Top Motivated Business Buyers & Their Requests!

If you're trying to sell a business - check out this week's top 100 business buyers - one of these buyers may be looking to buy your type and location of business! This list is updated weekly - make sure you check it frequently! Are you searching to buy - get on this list and reach seller direct!

Need Financing To Buy A Small Business? Business Purchase Financing Details

What are actual adjusted net earnings (cash flow) of a small business being purchased with business acquisition financing? That's an important amount that lenders need to know. Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen.com's Lead Advisor - ProBuy/ProSell Programs) reviews this concept with BizBen Blog readers.

Tips For Faster SBA Loan Approvals For California Small Business Purchases

In this article on BizBen, business purchase financing advisor and SBA loan broker, consultant Peter Siegel (Business Purchase Financing Expert/Advisor & the ProBuy Program Director at BizBen) at 925-785-3118 shares his views of getting SBA loan financing faster for business purchase financing.

Buy A Business Or Start From Scratch? 5 Key Differences For Business Buyers

Some buyers believe it's better to start a business from scratch rather than buy an existing enterprise. While this may be good advice in some cases, usually it's not the best strategy. Here are five tips to help a buyer make the right decision from from Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen Director).


Chuck Post Laundromat Industry Expert
Tim Cunha Business Brokerage
Escrow Services Diane Boudreau-Tschetter
Cheryl Maloney Restaurant Broker San Francisco
Facebook
Twitter
Linkedin
Vlogs and Podcasts
BizBen ProSell Program
Advertise On BizBen
BizBen ProBuy Program
Business For Sale California Stats
California Educational Events Buying And Selling Businesses
BizBen Blogs And Articles


BizBen - Where California Deals Get Done! 888-212-4747
7172 Regional Street #364 · Dublin, CA. 94568
BizBen · Copyright © 1994 - 2020, All Rights Reserved



Clost Login


Please confirm your registration by clicking the link we've sent to .

If you can't see it, please check your junk mail folder.

If you have any problems registering, or need assistance with your new BizBen User Account please phone BizBen Customer Support at 888-212-4747.



First Name:*
Last Name:*
Email Address:*
Confirm Email:*
Create Password:*
Confirm Password:*
Phone:
(   
 


You Are A:
Individual
 
Intermediary
 

Email Address:
Password:
 

500 New & Refreshed Detailed Postings Daily
Over 2500 Resources Available On BizBen
Since 1994. Where California Deals Get Done!
What Is The Typical Business Broker Fee For Sellers And Buyers? Who Pays...
Read More News
Should I Buy A Business That is Losing Money? Feedback From Top Advisors...
Read More News