Should brokers and agents be allowed to represent both the buyer and seller in a transaction? Isn't this a conflict of interest? Doesn't California civil code require that when there is only one agent in a deal, that the agent is required to be a dual agent?
These are the questions that I would like to address in this article. I do not want to get into a legal discussion of the points of law, since I am a CPA and a business broker, and not an attorney.
I would, however, like to discuss the business consequences of a broker being the sole agent in the transaction.
Let's define in simple language the three types of agency relationships. An agency is when one person acts as an agent/fiduciary/middle man for another. They have limited authority, but they are there to assist the principal they represent in the business transactions. Real estate agents, stockbrokers, insurance agents, and business brokers are all agents for their clients.
Who are the clients of a broker or agent? Everyone agrees the brokers represent the seller of the business. If the buyer has a business broker working for him, everyone agrees he is the agent of the buyer. Each of the brokers works for the benefit of their client.
What about when there is only one agent/business broker? In a real estate transaction it is clearly defined that the one agent will represent both the buyer and seller. In the area of business selling and buying, I have had discussions with many attorneys that say that is not necessarily true. A business listing broker can say he is not a dual agent (representing both buyer and seller) or many try not to specify, in writing what their legal relationship is. The courts are a lot stronger on this point of law. The courts feel that if there is only one broker that he is a dual agent if the broker helped the buyer in any way other than give information and accept offers. This, of course, must be proven in court, it is not automatic.
What is the legal effect of being a dual agent rather than just representing the seller? The agent has a much higher duty to protect the buyer. An example would be the length allowed for due diligence. If a broker wrote the contract so the buyer only had two days, this might not be considered protecting the buyer. Another issue is disclosing information about the seller's business that the broker knows or should have known is false. A dual agent must disclose any info related to the business, while a seller's agent might not have to.
The challenge comes when a listing broker, refuses to be a dual agent, even when I tell him he is acting like one. I just saw an agency disclosure form- that is required by law to explain the three different kinds of agency relationships; clearly explain that the agent is not a dual agent. The buyer did not have a clue that this was the case, even though he signed receipt of the form.
Now let us just forget the legal issue and talk plain talk. Why would a broker not be willing to be a dual agent? The commission is totally going to the listing agent, and it is very likely that the listing agent has refused to split his commission with an agent who wants to represent the buyer. Quite often the broker's response is that the buyer can pay the buyer's agent fee, if he wants representation.
When the buyer hires an experienced business broker, due diligence expert or attorney, at least someone is watching the buyer's back. When no such experienced help is hired, it is very likely that when the deal is completed, that he was been taken advantage of. After it is too late these unhappy buyers go to an attorney, only to find out it will cost thousands of dollars to sue and even then there is no guarantee of success. Even if you win a law suit, collecting the now hidden money the seller was paid, is also a big problem.
My recommendations are:
1. Hire an experienced CPA or business due diligence expert who has been involved with business brokering for years. They have looked at hundreds of leases, purchase contracts and financials.
2. Hire an attorney to review at least the purchase agreement and lease. They may or may not be able to help you with the financial and non-financial issues covered in due diligence.
3. Never do business with a broker or agent that refuses to represent both the buyer and seller in a transaction where there is only one broker. What is he doing or what does he know that he is so afraid of being sued by the buyer? By the way, the purchase contract and many other escrow forms clearly say that you have been advised to hire an adviser. When you don't you have lowering your chances of winning a law suit.
Buying a business is a major investment; it is one of the two biggest investments you will ever enter into. The big boys have a team of attorneys, CPAs, and brokers working for them. Even the small time sellers have professional advisors, and the buyers should have the same. When buying a business, you will quickly find that there are many people who have put their own interests ahead of your interests. You need at least one experienced professional on your side.
An attorney, CPA, Due diligence expert or a buyer's agent. It is preferable, of course, if you have two or more people watching your back, but take what you can get and afford.
It has been said, "A man who represents himself, has a fool as a client." and "It is very hard to watch your own back when you are looking forward."
About The Author: Willard Michlin, CPA (106752) offers business buyers Due Diligence Services (Second Opinion, Offer Assistance, Final Due Diligence) when they are thinking of making an offer on a business or in the process of investigating a business purchase. He has written numerous articles on the due diligence process and can be reached direct at 800-864-0420 for more information and an appointment.
|Helpful Resources To Assist In Selling And Buying California Businesses|
|Joanne Weber, Broker - Preschool Specialist - Southern California
The Ryan Craig Company is in its 35th year as the recognized expert in Southern California, dealing exclusively in the sale of preschools, Montessori schools, day care centers, and private schools. Our extensive list of references speaks for itself. Phone Joanne at 818-760-3684 for more info.
|Lee Petsas, Business Broker - Orange, San Diego Counties, Inland Empire
UBI Business Brokers has been successfully selling businesses in Southern California since 1965. Our Agents have over 100 years of experience in selling small to medium size businesses throughout Southern California. We service Orange County, Inland Empire, San Diego. Phone Lee at 714-363-0440.
|Michael Davidson, Business Broker - Southern California
Los Angeles Business Broker providing M&A quality services for Small Business Owners. We leverage our technology and expertise to Simplify & Expedite the Business Sales Process. Matching the right buyer with the right business is how we define success.
|Mike Brewer: Liquor License Brokers, ABC Consulting Services
Liquor license brokerage and consulting services. We provide: Alcohol License Transfers Application Consulting & Processing, Liquor License Purchases & Sales, City Zoning Permits & Land Use Entitlements, Public Convenience or Necessity Findings and Letters. Phone Mike Brewer direct at 800-437-1100.
|Peter Siegel, MBA - SBA Loans, Non SBA Financing Assistance
For over 25 years I have provided niche business purchase financial advisory and loan placement services with SBA and Non-SBA Loans, Retirement Plan Conversions, Private Investors, etc. Financing amounts available: $20K to $7MM. Call today to get pre-qualified or receive financing: 866-270-6278.
|Steve Zimmerman: Restaurant Broker Specialist
Steve founded Restaurant Realty in 1996. He has personally sold/leased over 900 restaurants, bars & clubs, & completed over 3000 valuations. The author of "Restaurant Dealmaker - An Insider's Trade Secrets For Buying a Restaurant, Bar or Club" available on Amazon. Reach Steve direct at 415-945-9701.
|Jack Oh, Business Broker - LA, Orange Counties
Business broker and real estate services in the Los Angeles and Orange County areas. 10 years experience with great negotiating skills. To sell a business or buy a business in the LA or Orange County Areas phone Jack and his team at 562-787-4989.
|Ron Hottes, Broker - Serving LA, Orange, Inland Empire Area
LINK Business is a business brokerage team of 28 highly skilled and seasoned professionals. Our business brokers have over 100 years of cumulative experience & the expertise to help you buy or sell a business in the LA County, Orange, Inland Empire areas. Call Ron for a consultation at 310-539-8300.
|Related Articles, Events, Blog Posts, Discussions, Videos, Interviews|
|What Are The Prospects Of Cannabis Based Small Businesses And Industry In CA
Jaime Ortega (at 866-591-7802), a Cannabis Industry Consultant, Due Diligence Specialist and Advisor reviews the new Administration's view & California's new legislation that will affect both buyers and sellers in the California Cannabis industry. Read what factors will affect both buyers & sellers.
|Cannabis Industry Consulting, Due Diligence Services - For Buyers, Start Ups
We offer Cannabis Industry Consulting & Due Diligence Services to business buyers, owners, sellers, entrepreneurs throughout CA. We offer assistance with: licensing issues, cultivation facilities, products/ services, dispensaries, corporate strategy, & project management. Call 866-591-7802 for info.
|Why Restaurant Buyers Typically Fail: Best Pro Tips For Buying A Restaurant
Buying a restaurant (no matter what type) can have many pitfalls, and potential restaurant buyers should know how to avoid getting burned! Several restaurant intermediaries and advisors weigh in on this BizBen Discussion about the best way to find, purchase and run a restaurant successfully!
|Webinar: CA Cannabis Industry Info And Overview: Buying, Selling, Starting
In this FREE on demand Webinar Jaime Ortega (at 866-591-7802) a Cannabis Industry Consultant, Due Diligence Provider, and Industry Advisor discusses different aspects of the cannabis industry and opportunities for buyers and entrepreneurs in this fast growing industry in California.
|Buying A Restaurant With Financing: 5 Options For Restaurant Business Buyers
In this Discussion, Peter Siegel MBA (Business Purchase Financing Advisor at 866-270-6278) discusses financing of purchasing a small to mid-sized restaurant business (with or without real estate). When it comes to financing a restaurant, potential restaurant buyers have many options to choose from.
|How To Buy A Vending Route: Multiple Tips For Vending Route Business Buyers
Some business buyers think they might like to buy a vending business but have heard negative things about the industry & aren't aware of important facts about this type of business. Here are some guidelines by Peter Siegel, MBA (Vending Route Financing Expert) at 866-270-6278 to help buyers.
|Due Diligence Checklist: 10 Key Items To Investigate When Buying Businesses
Buying a California small business involves reviewing due diligence checklists so buyers can learn enough to determine whether to proceed with a deal. Here's a due diligence checklist. Peter Siegel, MBA (BizBen ProBuy Advisor & Business Purchase Financing Expert) at 866-270-6278 shares his views.
|Financing The Purchase Of A Frozen Self-Serv Yogurt Shop - Tips For Buyers
Financing a frozen self-serv yogurt shop for can be challenging. Here, you'll learn the real scoop behind financing a yogurt shop purchase to help it be profitable from the start. Peter Siegel at BizBen.com
|See All News, Tips And Events|